Your Cart

New Mom Baby Gift


A dozen cookies delivered every 2 weeks for 8 weeks; a different flavor sent each week

Zero Trans FatZero Trans Fat
Dairy FreeDairy Free
Energy Boosting
No Additives

Our New Mom Baby Gift is the perfect present for any nursing mom! A dozen cookies beautifully wrapped arrives at Mom’s door every two weeks, each package a different flavor:

First Delivery: 12 Mocha Chip
Second Delivery: 12 White Chip Cranberry
Third Delivery: 12 Apple Pie
Fourth Delivery: 12 Chocolate Chunk

The perfect baby gift – practical, original, and fulfilling!

Nutrition features: Kosher, dairy-free, preservative-free, soy-free, and made in the USA by moms like you.

Ingredients: Oats, Flour, Canola Oil, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Eggs, Brewer’s Yeast, Water, Flaxseed, Raising Agent, Natural Flavors. May contain: Dark Chocolate, White Chocolate Chips, Apples, Dried Cranberries, Cookie Pieces, Coffee, Decaffeinated

Contains: Egg, Wheat

Allergy Information: Manufactured in a facility that also processes milk, soy, and nuts.

Additional information

Weight 14.8 oz
Dimensions 9.5 × 11 × 4.75 in
Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 3 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
United States United States

Highly Recommend!

I got a package as a gift and loved it so much that I've been recommending them to everyone I know! Recently my sister took me up on the recommendation and used Mommy's Cookie Jar cookies to get through a COVID milk supply dip when decongestants started drying her up. If you're on the fence, give these a try. They work and they taste amazing!


Best Gift!

This has definitely been the best baby gift I received! Perfect for me and for my new little bundle, you can't go wrong. They taste so good, I look forward to breakfast every morning (and an occasional midnight snack:). Can't wait to pay if forward and gift Mommy's Cookie Jar cookies to other new moms!

United States United States

Skeptic Turned Believer

I received these cookies as a gift and was really skeptical. In fact, I ended up eating them when I was totally blah and disillusioned with my crying baby. The cookies looked good and served as comfort food, or so I thought. I first had two and they were so good. Had to have another two with a cup of milk. By my baby's next feeding, I thought I was dreaming! I couldn't believe the difference! Can hardly wait to try the other flavors:)

Supports Breastfeeding

Mommy's Cookie Jar™ Cookies

Our exclusive mix of galactagogues, including Whole Oats, Brewer’s Yeast and Flaxseed naturally increase breast milk production. This unique combination together with the rest of our fine ingredients is how we produce our milk enhancing lactation cookies. 

Easier Pumping

Two Mommy's Cookie Jar™ Cookies a Day

All natural individually wrapped cookies make it convenient to grab and go. With just two cookies a day, you get all the milk-boosting you need for a happy baby.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you are worried about milk supply, you can definitely start eating these cookies on your delivery day. Of course they are also perfect for whenever you notice a dip in supply!
Every breastfeeding mother is different, so you can consume as many or as few as you’re comfortable with. However, we recommend consuming 2 – 3 cookies on the first and second day, 2 cookies on the third and fourth day and 1 cookie per day going forward. Repeat during week two or whenever you feel that you need too!
I noticed a difference within a day of eating these cookies, and most moms see an increase within 2 or 3 days. We suggest giving it a week to see results, keeping in mind it also depends on how many you eat.

We recommend eating them 3-5 hours before you’d like to see an increase. If you were looking for more production around 9am, have a cookie for an early breakfast around 5am. If you were looking for a greater supply before bedtime at 10pm, we recommend a cookie for a mini after-dinner dessert at 6pm. It takes a little bit of trial and error to figure out what time works best for you!

You can store baked cookies at room temperature for 7-10 days in a sealed container or ziploc bag. You can also freeze what you don’t plan to eat right away for up to 6 months.
Yes, absolutely! All of the ingredients in our cookies are safe for anyone to eat, including your husband and children. And you don’t have to worry about your husband starting to lactate if he steals a few.
Yes, unless otherwise specified as we do sometimes bake a limited edition dairy run for special occasions.

Yes, our cookies are baked in Apron Masters Kitchen and certified kosher pareve (made with dairy equipment).

No, fenugreek is not an ingredient used in our cookies.

Yes, occasionally we post exclusive offers on Instagram.

Visit us on @mommyscookiejar.

Try eating less cookies, as you may only need to eat one a day to increase your supply.
Believe it or not, we get this question a lot! And the answer is NO!! There is no actual breast milk in lactation cookies, just ingredients that are known to increase Mom’s milk supply.
Our cookies contain what are called galactagogues which are ingredients that help promote milk production, namely, oatmeal, flaxseed, and brewer’s yeast.
Just like any food, it’s best to enjoy the cookies in moderation! Aside from weight gain, eating too much of anything can actually create gaps in your diet, which is why it’s important to eat a variety of foods.